¡ LIVE NOW @ live.novaramedia.com !
psychiatry miners strike sussex psoe tef mike brown citizenship marxism sophie lewis refusal anarchism morsi romania hamas dale farm nus nhs pensions miliband troika zero hours tuition fees debt hotels Police desire communism david cameron print media international eleanor penny facebook martin lewis sian berry sussex five housing socialist establishment charlie lahr comedy protests work full unemployment mark carney terrorism picketprofiteers native george osborne banks corbyn westminster poverty spanish civil war football fortress europe Labour Party james meadway uffc couriers sturgeon working class UKIP domestic violence social housing boycotts sweden climate finance plaid cymru social networks Race asylum primaries Media bias latin america depression international brigades open democracy economic ge2020 dan whittall revolt of the ladders new democracy ref frankfurt review uaf antifascism eurozone pops privacy rape nypd deficit landlords risk greek election mark zuckerberg libspill steel industry nurses momentum intersectionality precarious europe labour regeneration crime individualism post-fordism spain television theresa may christmas al qaeda france inflation barcelona en comu united left irish water solidarity cantona international development eu fianna fail oxi john mcdonnell university of london soas rmt bank of england safety nick clegg chuka umunna refusal of work independent media social movements books growth 15m engels unite consumption heathrow ahora madrid free papua presidential race 2016c saudi arabia direct action mhairi black cop21 ferguson police violence star trek syriza idf conservatives middle east capitalism help to buy cooperatives economics armenia freefede scotland trident gender England adam stoneman privatization projects pharmaceuticals strategy of refusal estate iraq migration sport treasury pluralism global debout Niki Seth-Smith right to buy fracking whiteness budget cnd borders rpi bingo charlie hebdo blockadia history forest fire synthetic hedge elon musk ACAB pasokification ge2012 reproductive rights izquierda unida intervention blair public sector gary barlow left unity sinn fein arms trade results armenians survivors people's assembly rabina khan spending big pharma Aaron Bastani kobane indonesia andrew dolan media journalism rape culture rent chris grayling nef iww david harvey midwives revolution electoralism university nationalism novara10k technology boko haram tony abbott benefits turkey tube bjp house of lords malcolm x colonialism krugman trolling barts health british empire rbi free education ncafc fees trade unions uber loans value womens liberation remembrance IndyRef environment mubarak magna carta zabludowicz michel temer migrants masons dilma rousseff prevent cup mental health week erdogan crimea indignados wages new labour gangs andy burnham denis o brien student loans london mayor localism energy strike deep state bennett ultras tax automation columnism memes austerity greece bds squatting jo johnson government london hague radical reformism 22o northern ireland ello wales he sexual assault ubi australia pfi brazil workplace reappropriation tabloids willetts industry asn interviews music precariousness reclaim the streets cities organising free syrian army workfare omar aziz bullshit jobs easter rising interest modi alienation dover mark regev reparations costas lapavitsas bis telefonica universal basic income videos romanichal asia sadiq khan student politics post-capitalism marx modern monetary theory evictions bell hooks red wedge roma bonuses radical lives ludova strana nase slovensko Tuzla canada social reproduction long read snp birmingham tower hamlets daesh community organising precarity buy-to-let ulu corruption politicians syrian civil war bnp tabitha bast higher education secret employee immigration footwear feminism genocide digital media care silicon valley jeremy hunt security legal aid aboriginal nuclear labour movement political economy newham literature local government ipr jeremy corbyn electoral reform neoliberalism m18 migrant labour uprising privatisation Dawkins james butler Claudia Jones youtube lobo reappropriation isil aid angela mcrobie conchita geography student strike ecology greens social democracy occupation unions housing benefit brexit mitterand syria mob councils ciudadanos spanish election burnham human rights arms industry visas vaga de totes uk left unionism assad kurdistan kerry funerals local media eurovision ecb usa education blockupy left bloc racism fascism climate change catalan independence financialisation obama bae systems strikes portugal pay space romani india paul nuttall class Centre Left property rights politics state reshuffle cable foreign policy libdems anxiety calais lse national liberation social media refugees productivity rojava morality bulgaria social cleansing yes scotand thatcher foreign aid demands Tom Abree not fair not safe far-right arran james legitimacy global warming Gentrification law leaders debate tampon tax social strike accessibility autonomism ual industrial action ge2015 degrowth publishing stealing atheism germany madness malawi science glasgow support money eu referendum free speech mexico rob ford culture revuelta de escaleras hydra another europe is possible edl pop culture transport yemen care work rotherham grexit utopia mcgettigan religion class struggle democracy junior doctors gdp novaraeu james meek bias natalie bennett kurds novara wire architecture trans populism sisi anti-capitalism mental health subversion yes scotland spaceX freedom of movement he white paper Scottish Independence israel russia manifesto radical housing network diane abbott rhodes uk uncut ttip comedians women jobs holocaust theft clr james carpenters unemployment future eric pickles focus e15 millbank health queer ireland cpi nato alia al ghussain catalunya cameron clegg environmentalism europe week Economy Secular Crisis jesus BBC varoufakis house of commons drones iran met arts food data zac goldsmith conference season cost of living catalonia warwick fuel poverty production armenian genocide rusell brand athens tax evasion living wage fbu david willetts prison netanyahu electoral fraud young people olympics student debt lgbt news travellers hollaback grants london underground tesla sexual violence isis sexism demographics police brutality ethics libertarianism tax reform apps migrant justice employment ukba west bank general election #copsoffcampus eire suicide europe tsipras salmond orientalism egypt pasok mark duggan coalition maria miller golden dawn riots divestment communities property new york nuit debout palm oil crisis students socialism property guardians Adam Ramsay homelessness islamophobia christianity housing action yarls wood world cup gypsies mayoral election pride Policing Elections internet ukraine war hospitality owen jones tactics is oil maps fe orange order iwgb balls renting slovakia putin hsbc privatisaton housing crisis YesVote magdalene laundries democrats bernie sanders age eastern europe obr uk industry esol marketing workers barclays inequality work ethic cuts rent strike welfare state student movement occupy west papua universities start up no borders airstrikes podemos bouchart hillary clinton deportation budget2014 deflation lawrence and wishart business basic income antiziganism pablo iglesias south america palestine tories detention protest imf green party tuc gaza britain first arab spring pay gap china paris attacks

Marx contra Dawkins

submit to reddit

“Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. (…) Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. (…) The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. (…) Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower.” (Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, 1843)

That would be Karl Marx, being smarter about religion than Richard Dawkins will ever be, 170 years ago. The same text include the line about religion as ‘the opium of the masses’, which is probably the most wildly misused line from Marx. Opium was a medicine and comfort while also being a potent drug – when the phrase is used to mean “LOL religious people are so dumb it’s like they’re on smack LOL I am the great rationalist”, it misses precisely Marx’s recognition of the *social function* of religion, as well as its contradictory content, as both protest against suffering and a consolation that often enables its perpetuation. On that consolatory function, this: I was raised Catholic. When my grandfather was in the weeks where he was dying, I found myself in Soho Square – for non-Londoners, the heart of London’s historical gay district – reading in the sun. To the east of the square is a Catholic church, one of first built after Catholics were allowed to build churches in England again. I received a phonecall telling me to come to the hospital this evening, because the time was coming near. I found myself walking into the church and sitting down on one of the back pews. I genuflected, because muscle memory is hard to overcome, even when you haven’t been in a church for many years. I didn’t pray. But I thought about the instinctive Catholicism, deep-rooted, of my grandfather’s generation. I thought of his early jobs, of which he was so proud, hauling flour on the docks at the age of 14 (“earning a man’s wage so young.”) I thought of his war service and its horrors. I thought of his hands, back and knees giving out because he had worked all the flex out of them. I thought of his particular stubbornness. I thought of him lying in a bed a few miles away on a drip, all the weight gone out of him. I thought of him ill-treated by the state, unwilling to provide in his last years a small measure of justice for what he had done for decades. The impossible inequality of that never-agreed contract. I thought we do struggle with the powers of this world, princes and potentates – Ephesians – and I thought about redemption. What would redeem the endless work, the stress, the privation and the loss of over eighty years. How to give thanks, also, that to be born in a tenement in Bermondsey was not always to die there. How to finally understand the attraction of the promise of redemption and the horizon of a new world, in which the manifest injustices – the things left unfinished – shall have passed away. I don’t believe the New Jerusalem is waiting for us. And I could see, walking out of that church, how such a promise might be an inducement to inaction. But I also thought how all the old stories and psalms had a better way of naming and giving shape to the – very normal – suffering of a boy losing his grandfather, the sense of a pain shared and repeated many thousands of times over the generations, and a sharpening rage for the quotidian misery that made up so much of his daily work. I don’t think this is an easy fable. In some way it restates the obvious, about pain and knowledge and reflection. Heart of a heartless world indeed.