¡ LIVE NOW @ live.novaramedia.com !
interest tories eric pickles cantona egypt sussex fe pasokification Tom Abree isil atheism omar aziz productivity justice london media legal aid television northern ireland post-capitalism ferguson capitalism state obama glasgow engels hotels idf boko haram palestine zero hours unite conservatives privatisation eleanor penny prevent uk coalition strategy of refusal buy-to-let ahora madrid sturgeon care housing benefit blockadia nationalism crisis israel colonialism eurovision clegg labour willetts economic miliband tactics ello barcelona en comu stealing pensions revuelta de escaleras rpi rotherham hydra womens liberation secret employee mental health roma ethics trans green party culture whiteness rent Craig McVegas Labour Party asia business iraq sexism snp asylum al qaeda george osborne utopia footwear spain edl uaf pluralism cooperatives autonomism Niki Seth-Smith racism organising tax reform jobs future ulu police brutality ultras care work demands newham marketing law trident right to buy pharmaceuticals eurozone costas lapavitsas drones free education automation tuition fees women employment solidarity riots start up benefits post-fordism funerals Race videos no borders tax thatcher pride rabina khan ual student politics property rights radical lives intersectionality greens russia social housing property labour movement novara wire greece netanyahu new democracy renting fascism hollaback angela mcrobie electoral fraud student loans space demographics housing plaid cymru student movement tuc results asn occupation prison 22o left mark carney university of london education bias evictions IndyRef health david cameron mental health week bonuses maria miller andrew dolan mark regev general election gdp krugman Elections wages Adam Ramsay fracking burnham international mark duggan Gentrification working class privacy deep state lawrence and wishart safety growth romanichal nus pfi maps budget2014 uprising sport david willetts airstrikes lgbt imf bank of england cuts environment ecb pay Policing subversion birmingham Aaron Bastani loans morality living wage magna carta athens cup ge2020 olympics red wedge warwick bell hooks germany gaza open democracy social networks london underground comedians new york morsi mubarak uk uncut precariousness troika cameron eire masons tower hamlets interviews individualism met ubi reproductive rights Economy religion young people west bank desire feminism yes scotand BBC andy burnham synthetic hedge protests psychiatry catalan independence electoral reform rent strike james meek Claudia Jones charlie hebdo privatization memes rbi people's assembly ncafc gary barlow middle east m18 travellers debt psoe economics bjp communities is refusal of work james meadway fianna fail tsipras budget spending orientalism ttip orange order natalie bennett balls councils libertarianism ireland india ACAB technology projects trolling housing crisis divestment millbank anxiety bingo local government catalonia treasury industrial action vaga de totes golden dawn citizenship cities university calais rojava clr james value localism greek election music trade unions new labour workplace reappropriation politicians nurses hospitality precarious europe focus e15 big pharma pasok fees columnism alia al ghussain electoralism neoliberalism he canada direct action oxi architecture kurdistan antiziganism europe tube estate nick clegg revolution support finance queer social reproduction sexual violence national liberation depression YesVote England aboriginal literature arran james Scottish Independence student debt anarchism deficit obr blair gender world cup publishing ukraine james butler occupy landlords portugal isis carpenters nato freefede internet adam stoneman theresa may manifesto barts health westminster syria history tax evasion comedy books Centre Left money david harvey geography poverty populism migrants nef hague public sector data yes scotland marxism unions romani christmas marx suicide help to buy antifascism sinn fein sussex five financialisation apps climate ipr rape culture chris grayling political economy salmond podemos native islamophobia banks china kerry revolt of the ladders silicon valley digital media paul nuttall Dawkins privatisaton reappropriation higher education legitimacy libdems Tuzla star trek madness frankfurt rusell brand eu lse bnp workers unemployment jesus theft immigration pay gap universal basic income facebook radical housing network mike brown catalunya homelessness usa syriza charlie lahr ge2012 cost of living nhs iww midwives 15m kurds inequality bennett oil inflation mhairi black class struggle arab spring Media bias irish water crime tabitha bast left unity france mcgettigan police violence football welfare state christianity reclaim the streets Secular Crisis martin lewis intervention uffc review kobane sophie lewis consumption Police rmt community organising dan whittall scotland production precarity crimea hsbc bouchart politics conchita deflation cpi basic income work mob strikes protest jeremy corbyn age class blockupy brazil conference season sisi dale farm social movements leaders debate free speech ge2015 pop culture socialist UKIP modi security government cable barclays social cleansing nypd austerity holocaust journalism terrorism housing action accessibility mark zuckerberg gypsies uber hamas rape jeremy hunt rob ford owen jones putin miners strike chuka umunna #copsoffcampus pablo iglesias britain first arms industry malcolm x anti-capitalism refusal strike grexit workfare lobo telefonica

Marx contra Dawkins

submit to reddit
Pocket

“Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. (…) Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. (…) The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. (…) Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower.” (Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, 1843)

That would be Karl Marx, being smarter about religion than Richard Dawkins will ever be, 170 years ago. The same text include the line about religion as ‘the opium of the masses’, which is probably the most wildly misused line from Marx. Opium was a medicine and comfort while also being a potent drug – when the phrase is used to mean “LOL religious people are so dumb it’s like they’re on smack LOL I am the great rationalist”, it misses precisely Marx’s recognition of the *social function* of religion, as well as its contradictory content, as both protest against suffering and a consolation that often enables its perpetuation. On that consolatory function, this: I was raised Catholic. When my grandfather was in the weeks where he was dying, I found myself in Soho Square – for non-Londoners, the heart of London’s historical gay district – reading in the sun. To the east of the square is a Catholic church, one of first built after Catholics were allowed to build churches in England again. I received a phonecall telling me to come to the hospital this evening, because the time was coming near. I found myself walking into the church and sitting down on one of the back pews. I genuflected, because muscle memory is hard to overcome, even when you haven’t been in a church for many years. I didn’t pray. But I thought about the instinctive Catholicism, deep-rooted, of my grandfather’s generation. I thought of his early jobs, of which he was so proud, hauling flour on the docks at the age of 14 (“earning a man’s wage so young.”) I thought of his war service and its horrors. I thought of his hands, back and knees giving out because he had worked all the flex out of them. I thought of his particular stubbornness. I thought of him lying in a bed a few miles away on a drip, all the weight gone out of him. I thought of him ill-treated by the state, unwilling to provide in his last years a small measure of justice for what he had done for decades. The impossible inequality of that never-agreed contract. I thought we do struggle with the powers of this world, princes and potentates – Ephesians – and I thought about redemption. What would redeem the endless work, the stress, the privation and the loss of over eighty years. How to give thanks, also, that to be born in a tenement in Bermondsey was not always to die there. How to finally understand the attraction of the promise of redemption and the horizon of a new world, in which the manifest injustices – the things left unfinished – shall have passed away. I don’t believe the New Jerusalem is waiting for us. And I could see, walking out of that church, how such a promise might be an inducement to inaction. But I also thought how all the old stories and psalms had a better way of naming and giving shape to the – very normal – suffering of a boy losing his grandfather, the sense of a pain shared and repeated many thousands of times over the generations, and a sharpening rage for the quotidian misery that made up so much of his daily work. I don’t think this is an easy fable. In some way it restates the obvious, about pain and knowledge and reflection. Heart of a heartless world indeed.